What is meant by collusion and collusive behaviour?
The term collusion has been raised in several official reports and inquiries related to the Northern Ireland Troubles over the past two decades.
But what does it mean?
It is worth stating there is no offence of collusion, although it may involve a criminal act. It has been said to have many faces.
Generally, it covers a broad range of behaviours, from deliberate wilful actions to "a look the other way" approach.
There is no universally-accepted definition of collusion, but from 2003 onwards judges and others have spelled out what it means in a Northern Ireland context.
Two opinions became heavily relied upon at an early stage.
Sir John (now Lord) Stevens, when he was commissioner of the Metropolitan Police, was among the first to investigate ties between state security forces and loyalists.
He said collusion ranged from "the wilful failure to keep records, the absence of accountability, the withholding of intelligence and evidence, through to the extreme of agents being involved in murder".
Shortly after this, Canadian judge Peter Cory was appointed to examine collusion allegations in six specific cases.
He formed the view that any definition needed to be reasonably broad "because of the necessity of public confidence" in state forces such as the police.
For Judge Cory, it covered "ignoring or turning a blind eye to the wrongful acts of (state) servants or agents".
He also cited supplying agents with information to "assist in wrongful acts", or "encouraging them" to commit offences.
The views of Judge Peter Smithwick are also worth noting.
He headed a tribunal of inquiry in the Republic of Ireland which found collusion between garda (Irish police) officers and the IRA in the murders of two Royal Ulster Constabulary officers.
He said collusion was not just the commissioning of an act, but also an "unawareness of something that one ought morally, legally or officially to oppose".
Different holders of the office of Police Ombudsman have adopted varying definitions.
Marie Anderson, the current ombudsman, has previously said she favoured a broad interpretation, reflecting the views of Lord Stevens and Judge Cory.
But there has been a tweak in phraseology.
Her particular terminology is "collusive behaviour" and this has its roots in a court case brought in 2020 by retired Royal Ulster Constabulary (RUC) officers around the ombudsman's powers.
In 2022, a group of officers were granted a judicial review of the ombudsman's legal right to make findings of collusive behaviour by the High Court.
The Northern Ireland Retired Police Officers Association wants statements issued by Marie Anderson to be declared unlawful.
This challenge remains ongoing.
-
Jessica Pegula eases past Barbora Krejcikova to seal Australian Open quarter-final spot... and American is now the HIGHEST seeded woman left in the tournamentIMF expects UK economy to shun recessionIn pictures: Coronation concert and UK street partiesAI 'godobeseher' Yoshua Bengio feels 'lost' over life's workGerman officials say knifeman who stabbed two people to death and wounded seven others in brutal train rampage is a stateless Palestinian Record numbers not working due to ill healthBanks warn of big increase in online scamsAconsequentlys widens losses as shoppers cut backClimate activists heckle Ted Cruz on The View: Whoopi Goldberg tells protesters to leave for trying to drown him out during shouting match over Trump, the election and January 6Meta loses millions as made to sell Giphy to Shutterstock
Next article:Executed Oklahoma death row inmate Benjamin Cole was given priconsequentlyn-issued 'religious meal' of vegetarian lasagna, salad, a tortilla and a fruit drink packet: Guards say he referred to himself as 'just a super-duper hyperbolic Jesus freak'
- ·Police on the hunt for prime suspect in murder of former NFL player Antonio Dennard after identifying handprint on car outside Reading, Pennsylvania bar
- ·Disney+ streaming business loses 4m subscribers in first quarter
- ·'Shocking' lack of evidence on antidepressants for chronic pain
- ·'Be very cautious' with 100% mortgages, says Bank
- ·Andrew 'Freddie' Flintoff 'puts his TV career on hold after horror Top Gear car crash': Ex-cricket ace 'was begged by his family to stay away from work as he recovers from injuries'
- ·Warning UK losing £2,300 per minute to fraud
- ·Vice and Motherboard
- ·Poor diabetes care may be behind 7,000 excess deaths
- ·ISIS-inspired terrorist who killed eight with truck in NY is convicted
- ·Jaguar Land Rover
- ·Flooding: Toilet bungs and other prevention measures to save homes
- ·ChatGPT: Can students pass using AI tools at university?
- ·British woman is found dead along with Swedish man in a tourist acomponentment in Portugal, sparking police investigation
- ·Tears of the Kingdom: Fans react to Zelda sequel launch
- ·Food price inflation dips for second month in a row
- ·Prince Louis drives a digger as he joins volunteering efforts
- · End of an era for Wally Lewis as rugby league great reveals he had to make huge life convert 'for my health' amid battle with epilepsy
- ·Twitter hack: 130 accounts targeted in attack
- ·Bank of England chief economist consequentlyrry for 'inflammatory' comment
- ·Aconsequentlys widens losses as shoppers cut back
- ·Police are granted more time to quiz Leeds hospital 'terror suspect': Man, 27, who was 'armed with a gun and viable explosive device' to be held in custody for a week
- ·Asda buys petrol station grohigh EG for £2.3bn
- ·Food price inflation dips for second month in a row
- ·British Airways cancels dozens of Heathrow fradiants after IT problem
- ·People urged to cash in unutilized energy bill shighport vouchers
- ·Hacker marketplace still active notwithstanding police 'takedown' claim
- ·Jeremy Renner shares photo of physical therapy session and reveals he's suffered more than 30 broken bones after star was almost crushed to death by 14,000-pound snowplow
- ·Neuralink: Why is Elon Musk’s brain chip firm in the freshs?
- ·Ovo and Good Energy customers to get refunds after overcharging
- ·Chip war: Apple strikes major US
- ·Ronna McDaniel WINS fourth term as Republican National Committee chair after hideous leadership battle with Harmeet Dhillon - and will steer GOP to 2024 elections notwithstanding underwhelming midterms
- ·Elon Musk names Linda Yaccarino new Twitter boss
- ·Vice and Motherboard
- ·Asda buys petrol station grohigh EG for £2.3bn
- ·Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett REJECTS emergency bid to block Biden's student loan relief plan by group claiming it's unconstitutional and taxes most Americans
- ·Can you get incostlyer wideband deals with consequentlycial tariffs?